Highway collision, disputed liability
$1.4M recovered after the insurer's third and final offer was refused.
Read the matter: Highway collision, disputed liabilityFor nearly four decades Blackstone Legal has represented families, founders and businesses through the moments that decide everything. You get a named partner, a written strategy, and a straight answer — every time.
In the autumn of 1987, Arthur J. Blackstone hung a shingle above two rented rooms on Pearl Street with one clerk, a borrowed desk and a rule he wrote on the back of a case file: never let a client learn something about their own matter from anyone but us.
That rule outlasted the desk. It is why every file here still carries a named partner, why our engagement letters state a strategy in plain English before a single hour is billed, and why clients who came to us for a first apartment closing now send us their companies.
Nearly four decades on we are eighteen attorneys across New York and Boston, practising in five disciplines. We have argued before the Appellate Division, closed nine-figure transactions and sat at kitchen tables at midnight. The work changed scale. The rule did not.
Arthur J. Blackstone opens a two-room practice on Pearl Street.
First appellate victory; the family law group is formally established.
Corporate & transactional practice founded for founder-led businesses.
The firm moves into its present chambers at 120 Justice Avenue.
Pro bono programme passes 10,000 hours of donated counsel.
Named Firm of the Year by the Metropolitan Bar Review.
Our floor at 120 Justice Avenue was restored in 2011 and we kept everything worth keeping: the 1908 plasterwork, the reading room, and the long table where every case strategy still gets argued out loud before it ever reaches a client.
Drag to look around
120 Justice Avenue, Suite 900, New York, NY 10007 Arrange a visit
We deliberately stayed narrow. These are the five areas we have practised since the beginning — deep enough that the partner reading your file has almost certainly argued your issue before.
The matters that decide where your children sleep and what you keep. We handle them with the discretion they deserve and the pressure they sometimes require.
Counsel for founder-led companies from the first cap table to the exit — commercial, practical and written so a non-lawyer can act on it.
From the first phone call to the verdict. We take the cases seriously, we take the timeline seriously, and we never promise an outcome we cannot argue for.
You pay nothing unless we recover. We handle the insurer, the paperwork and the medical record so you can concentrate on getting better.
Residential and commercial, from a first closing to a mixed-use development — with the title work done properly the first time.
Most people who call us have never instructed a lawyer before. So we made the process legible: here is exactly what happens, in what order, and what it costs.
Thirty minutes with a partner, free and without obligation. You describe the situation; we tell you plainly whether you have a matter worth pursuing.
Within three business days you receive the route, the realistic outcomes, the timeline and the fee — in plain English, before anything is billed.
A named partner runs the file and stays on it. You get updates as things move, not when you chase — and a reply inside one business day.
Settlement, closing or judgment — then a closing letter that sets out what was achieved and what you should keep on file.
Large enough to take on institutional opponents, deliberately small enough that the person who meets you is the person who argues your case.
Your matter is never handed down to whoever is free. The partner you meet at the consultation signs the closing letter — and takes your calls in between.
If your case is weak we will tell you at the consultation, for free, rather than bill you to find out slowly. Roughly one in six enquiries leaves with advice and no invoice.
Fixed fees wherever the work allows it, contingency for injury matters, and a written estimate before we start. No surprise invoices — that is a policy, not a slogan.
$1.4M recovered after the insurer's third and final offer was refused.
Read the matter: Highway collision, disputed liabilitySettled in 9 weeks with the contract restructured and the trading relationship intact.
Read the matter: Breach of a supply agreementJoint custody preserved and the relocation application dismissed at first hearing.
Read the matter: Contested custody, relocation opposedCharges dismissed after the traffic stop was found to lack reasonable suspicion.
Read the matter: Felony DUI, unlawful stopTitle quieted and the disputed strip conveyed without proceeding to trial.
Read the matter: Boundary and easement disputeClosed in 6 weeks with deferred consideration secured against company assets.
Read the matter: Founder exit and share buy-backThey handled my custody case with real care and never left me guessing. I always knew the plan and the next step before it happened.
Straight answers, no inflated promises. They restructured our contracts and saved the deal without the drama I expected from lawyers.
After my accident I felt out of my depth. Their team took over the paperwork and the insurer, and won more than I thought possible.
I called on a Sunday expecting a machine. A partner rang back within the hour and talked me through the arraignment step by step.
Our closing had collapsed twice with another firm. Blackstone found the title defect in a week and we completed inside the month.
What I valued most was the written strategy up front. I knew the cost, the timeline and the realistic outcome before I committed.
They talked me out of suing. It would have cost me more than it was worth, and they said so in the first meeting, for free.
Twenty-two years of my business, three acquisitions, one difficult exit — same partner on the phone every time. That continuity is rare.
My mother's estate was a mess of old paperwork. They were patient with her, patient with me, and never once made us feel rushed.
Plain English, every time. I never needed to ask what a letter meant, which after my last solicitor was worth the fee on its own.
Hover to pause · 10 of 320 reviews
The questions we are asked most often, answered the way we would answer them on the phone. If yours isn't here, ask it at the consultation — it costs nothing.
Ask us directlyYes — thirty minutes with a partner, with no obligation and no invoice, whatever you decide afterwards. If we don't think you have a matter worth pursuing we will say so during that call rather than bill you to find out slowly.
Three ways, depending on the work. Fixed fees for defined matters such as closings, incorporations and uncontested filings. Contingency for personal injury — you pay nothing unless we recover. Hourly for litigation and complex corporate work, always against a written estimate agreed before we start.
Enquiries sent through this site are answered within one business day. Existing clients on active criminal matters have a 24-hour arrest line. If a deadline is running against you, say so in your message and we will move it to the front.
A named partner owns your file from the consultation to the closing letter. Associates and paralegals support the work — that is what keeps fees sensible — but your matter is never handed down to whoever happens to be free that week.
Whatever you already have: correspondence, contracts, court papers, police reports, photographs, insurance documents. Don't delay the call to assemble a perfect file — a rough chronology written in your own words is often the most useful thing you can bring.
Our attorneys are admitted in New York, New Jersey, Connecticut and Massachusetts, and we run a second office in Boston. For matters elsewhere we will either appear pro hac vice where permitted or refer you to counsel we know personally — at no cost to you.
Thirty minutes with a partner, free of charge. You'll leave the call knowing whether you have a case, what it would realistically involve, and what it would cost.
Tell us about your situation and a partner will come back to you with clear, honest guidance — usually the same day.
We reply within one business day. Nothing you send here creates an attorney–client relationship — please don't include confidential details yet.
A warehouse supervisor was told by three separate adjusters that he had caused his own injuries. Nineteen months later the carrier's insurer paid $1.4 million rather than put its driver's logbook in front of a jury.
Shortly after six on a wet March morning, our client was driving north on the Major Deegan when a tractor-trailer moved out of the centre lane into his. The trailer's rear axle caught the offside of his pickup, spun it through ninety degrees and put it into the barrier. He was forty-one, and he was on his way to a shift he had worked for eleven years.
He walked away from the scene, which is often the worst thing that can happen to an injured person's case. The fracture at L1 did not announce itself until the following evening. It was surgically fused nine days later. He was out of work for eleven months and came back to a permanent twenty-pound lifting restriction that his employer could not accommodate on the floor.
No citation had been issued at the scene. The police report recorded two contradictory accounts and drew no conclusion. On that foundation the carrier's insurer built a position it held for fourteen months: that our client had drifted left, that the trailer had nowhere to go, and that he was sixty per cent responsible for his own injuries.
It made three offers. Ninety-five thousand dollars, then a hundred and eighty, then three hundred and ten thousand described in writing as full, final and not open to negotiation. Against a fusion, a year of lost earnings and a career he could no longer do, the third offer would have been spent before his youngest finished school. He refused it and came to us the same week.
The insurer's case rested entirely on the absence of evidence. Our work was to remove that absence — to replace two contradictory statements with a record that could be tested.
The matter settled at mediation three weeks before jury selection for $1.4 million, roughly four and a half times the offer he had been told was final. Comparative fault was abandoned entirely; the settlement was recorded without any allocation against him.
Part of the recovery was structured to fund the revision surgery his surgeon expects in the next decade. We negotiated the health insurer's lien down by a little over sixty thousand dollars before disbursement, which is money that stayed with the client rather than with a subrogation department.
Three adjusters told me it was my fault. Priya was the first person who asked to see the truck instead of asking me to explain myself again.
A disputed-liability collision is won or lost in the first month, before the vehicle is repaired and the electronic data is overwritten. If an insurer has told you that you were partly at fault, the assessment costs you nothing and we will tell you plainly whether the evidence can still be recovered.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.
Our client wanted to sue the supplier that had stopped delivering. We advised against it, and got the money anyway — because the supplier was still the only company in the country that could make the ingredient.
Our client is a speciality food manufacturer in Queens with four production lines and a national retail listing it took nine years to win. One of its products depends on a proprietary emulsifier made by a single approved supplier under a three-year exclusive agreement with take-or-pay minimums.
In the autumn the supplier began retooling its plant. Deliveries slipped in October, missed entirely in November, and arrived at forty per cent of contract volume in December. Our client air-freighted a partial substitute at eleven times the ground rate, missed two retail replenishment windows and took chargebacks on both. By the time it called us it was facing a delisting review in the new year.
The instruction we were given was to sue for everything. That was an understandable instinct and the wrong strategy, and we said so at the first meeting.
Three things drove that advice. The supplier was the only source qualified under the client's own food-safety approvals, and requalifying a second one takes months. The liquidated damages clause the client wanted to enforce was drafted at a level a court could well have struck down as a penalty rather than a genuine estimate of loss. And litigation would have run past the delisting review it was meant to prevent. Winning in eighteen months would have meant winning after the shelf space was gone.
Signed and documented nine weeks from instruction. No complaint was filed and no court fee was paid. Full-volume deliveries resumed five weeks in, ahead of the replenishment window; the delisting review closed without action and the listing was retained.
The second source completed qualification the following summer, which means the exposure that created this matter no longer exists. The client and the supplier are still trading.
I came in wanting a lawsuit. Marcus talked me out of it in about twenty minutes and then got me more than the lawsuit was worth. We still take that supplier's calls.
Commercial disputes with a counterparty you still need are a different exercise from disputes with one you do not. The first step is always the same: read the contract properly, put the notice out correctly, and decide afterwards. If you are inside a cure period the clock is already running.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.
There is no winning a custody case. There is only a seven-year-old who still sees her father on a Tuesday, and a schedule that survives the year her parents did not.
Our client and his former wife separated two years before we were instructed. Their settlement gave them joint legal custody and a genuinely shared physical arrangement — alternating weeks, handover on Sunday evening, two children then aged seven and ten. By every account we later put before the court, it was working.
In February the mother filed a petition to relocate roughly seven hundred miles for a promotion. The proposal offered our client the long school holidays and alternate Thanksgivings. In practical terms it would have ended a shared arrangement and replaced it with visits.
He came to us three days after being served, with a letter from the other side inviting him to consent and a school year that was due to end in four months. He believed, as many parents do, that a job offer settles the question.
It does not. New York applies the standard in Tropea v. Tropea: relocation is decided on the best interests of the child, weighing all the circumstances, with no presumption for or against the parent who wants to move. The court would look at each parent's relationship with the children, the effect of the move on the relationship that would be diminished, whether the move genuinely improves the family's life economically and emotionally, and whether the arrangement can be made to work another way.
What that meant in practice was that the case would be decided on evidence, and that the evidence about our client's day-to-day involvement had to exist in a form a judge could read.
The relocation petition was denied at the first evidentiary hearing. Joint custody was preserved and the alternating-week schedule continued unchanged. The right of first refusal was adopted into the order, as was the review mechanism.
The mother took one of the local roles identified in evidence. Both parents remain in the same school district and neither has been back to court.
Elena never once told me I was going to win. She told me exactly what the court would want to see and then helped me prove I had been doing it for three years.
Relocation matters move quickly and the first fortnight matters more than any other. If you have been served with a petition, or you have been asked to consent to a move, speak to someone before you reply in writing. The consultation is free and confidential, and we will tell you honestly how your position looks.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.
We do not argue that our clients are always innocent. We argue that the state has to do it properly — and in this matter the ninety seconds of video before the lights came on showed that it had not.
Our client was stopped at twenty to midnight on a two-lane county road. The stated basis was that his nearside tyre had briefly touched the fog line. He performed field sobriety tests at the roadside, was arrested, and gave a breath sample at the station that read .11.
Because he had a prior conviction within ten years, the charge came back as a class E felony rather than a misdemeanour. He was thirty-six, drove a delivery route for a living, and held the commercial licence that route depended on. He was facing up to four years, a revocation, and the end of the only trade he had.
He had already been offered a plea at arraignment and had been advised informally that a reading over the limit made the case unwinnable. That is a common piece of advice and it is often wrong, because it answers the wrong question. A breath reading is only evidence if the stop that produced it was lawful.
Everything the prosecution had — the observations, the roadside tests, the breath result, the statements he made in the patrol car — flowed from a single decision by a single officer to pull him over. If that decision was not supported by reasonable suspicion, none of the rest of it was admissible. So the question was never whether he had been drinking. It was whether there had been a lawful reason to stop him at all.
The court held that the stop was not supported by reasonable suspicion. The observations, the field sobriety tests, the breath result and the statements were all suppressed as fruit of the unlawful stop. With nothing admissible left, the People could not proceed and the felony charge was dismissed in its entirety.
The refusal hearing was resolved in his favour. He kept the licence, kept the commercial endorsement and kept the route.
Two people told me to take the plea. Sam asked for the video first. It turned out the reason they stopped me was not on it.
Electronic evidence in a traffic matter is not kept indefinitely, and some of it is overwritten within weeks. If you have been charged, ask about the footage before you decide anything else. We take the arrest line twenty-four hours a day for clients on active criminal matters.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.
Eleven feet of a suburban side yard, a fence put up on a Saturday, and a surveyor in 1978 who measured from the wrong iron pipe. Most boundary disputes are decided by a document nobody has read in forty years.
Our clients bought a 1926 house on a half-acre plot and spent two years restoring it. In the spring their neighbour erected a six-foot fence along what he said was the boundary. It sat eleven feet inside the line our clients had been shown at closing, and it enclosed the only vehicle access to the rear garden along with the septic clean-out.
The neighbour's position was that the fence followed a survey commissioned in 1978, that the strip had been treated as his family's for decades, and that in any event he had acquired it by adverse possession. He also claimed a prescriptive easement over the shared driveway apron, which would have limited what our clients could do with their own frontage.
They had done the sensible thing first — talked to him, then written to him — and had received a letter from his attorney that read as a settled position. Their concern was that they could not get an oil delivery to the rear tank, could not reach the clean-out without crossing the fence, and had a boundary that would have to be disclosed to any future buyer.
Two questions had to be answered in order. Where was the line, as a matter of record? And if the record put the strip with our clients, did anything the neighbour had done since take it away again?
The neighbour's counsel conceded the monument error at the second settlement conference. Under the recorded stipulation the fence was removed and reinstated on the true line at his expense, title to the disputed strip was quieted in our clients' favour, the adverse possession and prescriptive easement claims were discontinued with prejudice, and a reciprocal driveway easement was recorded against both properties.
No trial, no appeal. The title insurer met the survey costs and the bulk of the fees. Access to the rear garden and the clean-out was restored before the heating season.
We assumed it would be our word against his. It turned out to be a pipe in the ground that had been there since 1926, and a firm that thought to go and look for it.
Boundary disputes get more expensive the longer they run and harder to resolve once a structure is built. If a fence, wall or extension has gone up near your line, get the survey and the title file reviewed before you respond to the letter. Your title policy may already cover the cost.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.
A departing founder, twenty-eight per cent of the equity, two code repositories that had never been assigned to the company, and a fundraising conversation running in parallel that nobody wanted to disturb.
Our client is a software company eleven years old, three founders, around forty staff. The technical founder — twenty-eight per cent of the equity and the company's chief technology officer — decided to leave. It was not a falling-out. He had been at it for a decade, he was tired, and he wanted to convert a paper holding into money.
The shareholders' agreement was of no help. Its only exit machinery was a right of first refusal drafted in 2016 for a much smaller company, with no valuation mechanism, no deferred payment terms and nothing about what happens to a departing founder's ongoing obligations. Meanwhile the board had opened early conversations with a growth investor, and a disorderly founder exit appearing in diligence would have repriced or ended them.
The commercial problem was straightforward and awkward. The company held about $2.1 million in cash. A full cash buy-out at any defensible valuation would have taken most of it and stopped the hiring plan the investor conversation was predicated on. Paying nothing was not an option either: the departing founder was entitled to be bought out and, more to the point, everybody wanted him to leave on good terms.
The legal problem was the one nobody had looked for. Before we papered anything we ran diligence on our own client, which is not the usual instinct on a friendly deal and is where the value was.
Signed and closed six weeks from instruction, with no disruption to trading and none to the investor conversation, which continued on its original terms. The IP chain went into that diligence clean, which is a defect the company would otherwise have discovered under pressure and paid for.
The deferred consideration was settled in full four months ahead of schedule out of trading cash. The security was discharged and the founder's release took effect on the same day.
We asked for a share purchase agreement. What we got was someone telling us we did not own two of our own repositories, six weeks before an investor would have found out.
Founder exits are cheapest while everyone is still on speaking terms and most expensive once a deadline is attached. If a shareholder wants out, or your shareholders' agreement has not been looked at since incorporation, an early review costs far less than the alternative.
Book a free consultationPrior results do not guarantee a similar outcome; every matter turns on its own facts. Blackstone Legal is a fictional firm and this page is a design showcase — the matter described here, along with all names, figures and quotations, is illustrative.